9/20/2012, Natalee Grace Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Natalee Grace Collection of Used U.S. Stamps, Part Three: 1902 and Later Issues, Sale 1028, Lot 339, Realized $6,500
2/28/2017, The Barry K. Schwartz Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Barry K. Schwartz Collection of The U.S. 1909 Bluish Paper Issue, Sale 1148, Lot 120, Realized $6,000, Description notes "For the record, the P.F. issued a certificate stating “counterfeit cancel and reperforated at bottom”
Certificates:
PSE 19403 Genuine
PSE 1210292 Genuine
PF 473528 IT IS A SCOTT 359, WITH A COUNTERFEIT CANCEL, AND REPERFORATED AT BOTTOM
This was submitted to the PF in 1991 as an unused stamp, and received a certificate noting "Genuine, previously hinged and reperforated at bottom". It sent into the PF again, in 2008, as a used stamp.
Provenance:
2/25/2015, Michael Bakwin Collection, Matthew Bennett Auctions, The Michael Bakwin Collection of Used United States, 1847-1947, Sale 351, Lot 169, Realized $6,750
Certificates:
PF 242566 (1991) Genuine, previously hinged and reperforated at bottom