6 West 48th Street
9th Floor
New York, NY 10036

Contact by phone:
New York: (212) 753-6421
Dallas: (214) 754-5991

Census of 5c Hawaiian Missionary (Scott HI2)
62 Census Records

Back to Census Summary of 2

Back to the Siegel Census

3 Sound 2 Fault

2-I-UNC-16

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Repaired tear at BR, VF appearance

Provenance:

Found by Ezra Cole 4/57
Lilly, Collector C

Certificates:

2-II-UNC-17

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Repairs, rebacked with margins added and framelines drawn in

Provenance:

Tows (lot 241), Lilly (lot 128)
Collector C

Certificates:

2-I-UNC-18

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Large part restored and painted in, two tears (one interior)

Provenance:

Burrus Collection, Ostheimer
Honolulu Advertiser Collection

Certificates:

2-II-UNC-19
Fault

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Described as unused and repaired in Tows sale, no further information

Provenance:

Tows Collection, Lot 242
5/31/2016, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2016 Rarities of the World, Sale 1129, Lot 458, Realized $18,000

Certificates:

PF 1327 (1948) Genuine

2-I-UNC-20

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Top Margin added, sealed tear at L

Provenance:

Possibly Wolters (where described with top cut in, tear at L, and trace of red cds at BL)
6/18/2011, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2011 Rarities of the World, Sale 1010, Lot 187, Realized $22,000

Certificates:

2-I-UNC-21

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Repaired TR corner and painted in

Provenance:

Tapling (British Library)

Certificates:

2-II-UNC-22

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Repaired
Small faults, repaired at LR corner

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-I-UNC-23

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Defective
No repair described in Green sale but realized $1,000 vs. $7,000 (probably used or defective)

Provenance:

Green Collection

Certificates:

2-I-UNC-24

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Defective
No details available

Provenance:

Tapling (British Library)

Certificates:

2-I-UNC-25

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Minor Faults
No repairs, few small flaws, toning at B

Provenance:

Lichtenstein, Collector C

Certificates:

2-II-UNC-26

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Condition: Minor Faults
No repair, described with “part original gum” in Burrus sale, tiny tears and stain, VF appearance

Provenance:

Burrus Collection, Harris
Possibly Worthington

Certificates:

2-II-UNC-27
Sound

Notes:

Cancellation: Unused
Mounted on card, margins slightly cut in, no repair

Provenance:

Ferrary Collection
Burrus Collection
Ostheimer Collection
11/7/1995, Honolulu Advertiser - $42 Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 15, Realized $42,500, 500 hammer
5/29/2016, William H. Gross Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The William H. Gross Collection: Hawaii, Sale 1126, Lot 5, Realized $40,000

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-28

Notes:

Cancellation: Indistinct cancel
Condition: Repaired
Repaired and described as used on PFC

Provenance:

Tows Collection, Lot 240

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-29

Notes:

Cancellation: Indistinct cancel
Condition: Repaired
Genuine portion of stamp with large parts added and drawn in

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-30

Notes:

Cancellation: Indistinct cancel
Condition: Defective
Heavily wrinkled and faulty

Provenance:

C. Brown (on piece)

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-31

Notes:

Cancellation: Cancel removed
Condition: Repaired
Pen cancel removed, repaired

Provenance:

Bowers (Colson Book)
Ishikawa Collection, possibly Worthington

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-32

Notes:

Cancellation: Black Pen
Condition: Repaired
BR corner added and painted in

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-33

Notes:

Cancellation: Red Pen or Crayon
Condition: Defective
Tears

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-34

Notes:

"right margin added and small touch up of
frame-line at top right corner, vertical crease and few small faults"
Cancellation: Red Pen or Crayon

Provenance:

Atherton Collection
10/29/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaii, Sale 1112, Lot 1004, Realized $23,000

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-35
Sound

Notes:

Cancellation: Red Pen or Crayon
Border fragments show at top corners, no faults or repairs

Provenance:

Mirabaud Collection, Levitt, Ostheimer
Honolulu Advertiser Collection
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 18

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-36

Notes:

Cancellation: Large Grid & Red Pen
Condition: Defective
Faults not speciﬁed

Provenance:

Ferrary (4th Sale)

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-37

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu Hawaiian-Islands
Minor repaired tear and thin at TR, VF appearance.

Provenance:

Harris, Ishikawa
Collector C

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-38

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Repaired
Rebacked with margins and parts of frame-lines added

Provenance:

Clapp, Wilson, Harris, Collector C
6/18/2011, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2011 Rarities of the World, Sale 1010, Lot 188, Realized $42,500

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-39

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Repaired
Part of frame-lines added, re-backed and repaired

Provenance:

Wilson, Harris

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-40

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu, Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Repaired
Mounted on card, torn at left, cut into top

Provenance:

California Collection
6/25/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2015 Rarities of the World, Sale 1106, Lot 3177, Realized $25,000

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-41

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu, Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Defective
Faults, corners clipped

Provenance:

Ferrary (4th Sale)

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-42

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu, Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Defective
Piece missing at top

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-43

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu, Hawaiian-Islands
Condition: Minor Faults
Faults

Provenance:

Ferrary Collection, Ayer, (7th Sale), Hind

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-44

Notes:

Cancellation: Red cds Honolulu US Postage Paid
Condition: Repaired
Two tears and small repairs

Provenance:

Clapp, Harris, Ishikawa
5/21/1996, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1996 Rarities of the World, Sale 777, Lot 240, Realized $14,000
10/29/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaii, Sale 1112, Lot 1002, Realized $30,000

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-45

Notes:

Cancellation: Black SF cds - this is the only recorded 5c Missionary with a San Francisco date stamp
Condition: Repaired
Re-backed with minor portions of design drawn in

Provenance:

W.H. Crocker, Collector C
5/21/1996, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1996 Rarities of the World, Sale 777, Lot 239, Realized $13,000
12/16-17/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps and Possessions, Sale 1116, Lot 3636, Realized $21,000

Certificates:

PF (1994)

2-I-CAN-46

Notes:

Cancellation: Black SF cds
Condition: Repaired
BL corner restored, faults

Provenance:

Ferrary (4th Sale)

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-47

Notes:

Cancellation: Red Boston cds
Condition: Defective
EF appearance, small faults, Ishikawa catalog describes “minor repairs”

Provenance:

Atherton Honolulu Academy of Arts
Honolulu Advertiser, Ishikawa
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 17, Honolulu Advertiser

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-48

Notes:

Cancellation: Crossed Bars
Condition: Repaired
Piece added and painted in at R, BL corner restored

Provenance:

W.H. Crocker, Ishikawa
Collector C, Twigg-Smith
3/6/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection of Hawaii Stamps and Covers, Sale 931, Lot 4003, Realized $27,000
6/27/2017, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2017 Rarities of the World, Sale 1159, Lot 315, Realized $22,000

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-49

Notes:

Cancellation: Crossed Bars
Condition: Minor Faults
B margin cut in, small faults

Provenance:

Ferrary Collection

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-50

Notes:

Cancellation: Crossed Bars
Condition: Minor Faults
A few wrinkles or creases as usual for Missionary stamps that are not repaired, couple tiny margin tears, hinge-sealed horizontal tear at upper left about halfway across above "Hawaiian" (almost invisible)

Provenance:

Atherton Collection
10/29/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaii, Sale 1112, Lot 1003, Realized $19,000

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-51

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Repaired
Small faults, skillful repair

Provenance:

Ishikawa Collection

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-52

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Repaired
Left margin repaired with 2/3 of frameline and half of “F” drawn in

Provenance:

Nassau Stamp Co. 1934
Isleham (Peyton) Collection

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-53

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Repaired
TL corner restored, faults

Provenance:

Twigg-Smith Collection
3/6/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection of Hawaii Stamps and Covers, Sale 931, Lot 4005, Realized $26,000

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-54

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Repaired
Creased, repaired with large portion on UL corner added and painted in

Provenance:

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-55

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Defective
No information available, presumed defective

Provenance:

Reichspost Museum

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-56

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Minor Faults
Mounted on card, small faults, R frameline cut into

Provenance:

Ferrary Collection, Burrus
10/29/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaii, Sale 1112, Lot 1001, Realized $30,000

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-57

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Minor Faults
Sealed tears at bottom, no repair
Brewster Census no. 2-II-Used-1

Provenance:

Ostheimer Collection
11/7/1995, Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 19, Realized $19,800
3/6/2007, Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection of Hawaii Stamps and Covers , Sale 931, Lot 4004, Realized $97,750
5/8/2009, Richard Collier Collection, Spink Shreves Galleries, The Richard Collier Colllection of Postally Used Stamps of the World, Sale 113, Lot 345, Realized $43,225

Certificates:

PF 297018 (1995) Genuine, small tear at bottom right
PF 477084 (2009) Genuine, with two small tears at bottom

2-II-CAN-58

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Minor Faults
Condition not veriﬁed

Provenance:

Atherton Collection

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-59
Fault

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid

Provenance:

Atherton Collection
5/21/1996, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1996 Rarities of the World, Sale 777, Lot 238, Realized $14,500
11/9/2016, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. Treasures of Philately from The Irwin Weinberg Inventory, Sale 1139, Lot 132, Realized $20,000, Irwin Weinberg Inventory
10/22/2014, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaiian Stamps and Covers, Sale 1083, Lot 1001, Realized $22,000

Certificates:

PF (1995) light horizontal crease and tiny thin at top

2-I-CAN-60

Notes:

Cancellation: Large Grid of Squares
Condition: Repaired
Rebacked with B margin and frameline added, upper corners added in margin

Provenance:

Collector C

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-61

Notes:

Cancellation: Large Grid of Squares
Condition: Repaired
Two repaired tears, BL corner repaired and drawn in, lightened cancel

Provenance:

Lichtenstein Collection
Ishikawa Collection

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-62

Notes:

Cancellation: Large Grid of Squares
Condition: Repaired
B sheet margin, huge margins to touched at UL, repaired

Provenance:

3/26-28/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, Outstanding United States Stamps, Sale 1040, Lot 2262, Realized $37,500
12/15-18/2020, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. and Hawaii Stamps and Postal History, Sale 1230, Lot 1399, Realized $40,000

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-63

Notes:

Cancellation: Large Grid of Squares
Condition: Repaired

Provenance:

Atherton Collection

Certificates:

2-II-CAN-64

Notes:

Cancellation: Indistinct Black Cork
Condition: Minor Faults
No repairs, small tear at R

Provenance:

Hind, Lot 724
Lichtenstein Collection
Collector C

Certificates:

2-I-CAN-198

Notes:

Provenance:

Nutmeg Sale 172 - from the "Capitol City" Collection, Lot 7285

Certificates:

PF 469210 (2008) it is genuine, with repairs covering tears, creases, thinning and small holes, portions of the design and framelines painted in, and the top left corner repaired and stained

2-II-PCE-65

Notes:

Cancellation: Red Pen or Crayon
Condition: Sound
Light Wrinkles

Provenance:

Hind, Duveen
Harris, Amundsen
Ishikawa

Certificates:

2-II-PCE-66

Notes:

Cancellation: 7-Bar Grid
Condition: Repaired
Small portion of TL corner repaired and painted in

Provenance:

“Troy” Collection

Certificates:

2-I-COV-67

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
No repair,two small tears at sides
Usage: Used on envelope from U.S. to Lahainaluna
Cancel on Stamp: Red Pen or Crayon
Honolulu/SF Pmks: None
To/Destination: Pouge, Lahainaluna

Provenance:

Caspary, Collector C
6/25/2013, Walske Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Steven C. Walske Collection of Hawaiian Postal History, Sale 1045, Lot 12, Realized $100,000

Certificates:

2-I-COV-68

Notes:

Condition: Repaired
Slightly into framelines at sides, lifted and mounted on paper, small repairs
Usage: On envelope front (edges restored)
Cancel on Stamp: Red cds Honolulu Hawaiian-Islands
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 7/12/54 SF 8/16/54
Vessel Dep/Arr: Restless 7/13 – 8/9/54
To/Destination: Gay, New London, CT

Provenance:

Dutcher (JKB)
Caspary Collection
Burrus Collection
Ishikawa Collection
5/29/2016, William H. Gross Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The William H. Gross Collection: Hawaii, Sale 1126, Lot 7, Realized $45,000

Certificates:

2-II-COV-69

Notes:

Condition: Repaired
Condition Notes: The stamp and the paper behind [the stamp] have been cut out of the address panel and reattached (in the past this has been mistaken for rebacking), minor creases and sealed tear, but no paper addition or repainting
Usage: On folded letter
Cancel on Stamp: 7-Bar Grid
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 2/16/53 SF 3/??/53
Vessel Dep/Arr: Jacqueline & Elise 2/19 – 3/17/53
To/Destination: Rogers, Lowell, MA

Provenance:

Potts Collection
Harris Collection
Ishikawa Collection
Golden Collection
5/29/2016, William H. Gross Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The William H. Gross Collection: Hawaii, Sale 1126, Lot 8, Realized $52,500

Certificates:

2-I-COV-70

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
Minor Tears, VF appearance
Usage: On folded cover, Gilman red forwarder hs
Cancel on Stamp: 7-Bar Grid
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 10/4/52 SF 11/1/52
Vessel Dep/Arr: Mary A Jones 10/6 – 10/26/52
To/Destination: Caminels, Portland, ME

Provenance:

Worthington Collection, Frank Godden (Trade)
Krug, Harris, Meroni, Collector C
4/23/1996, K.L. Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The K.L. Collection of Classic Rarities, Sale 776, Lot 35, Realized $260,000
12/7/2004, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Lake Shore Collection, Sale 888, Lot 228, Realized $135,000, Lake Shore
6/25/2013, Walske Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Steven C. Walske Collection of Hawaiian Postal History, Sale 1045, Lot 13, Realized $100,000
10/22/2014, Siegel Auction Galleries, Hawaiian Stamps and Covers, Sale 1083, Lot 1003, Realized $110,000

Certificates:

2-I-COV-71

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
Light crease and tiny tear at R from file fold
Usage: On folded letter from Maui
Cancel on Stamp: 7-Bar Grid
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 1/18/53 SF 2/18/53
Vessel Dep/Arr: Excel 1/19 – 2/16/53
To/Destination: Brittan, San Francisco, CA

Provenance:

H.J. Crocker, Atherton
Honolulu Academy of Arts
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 1, Honolulu Advertiser

Certificates:

2-II-COV-72
After file fold restoration

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
Tiny sealed tear at B, wrinkles at T
Usage: On folded letter w/Porter & Ogden hs
Cancel on Stamp: 7-Bar Grid
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 9/11/52 SF 10/4/52
Vessel Dep/Arr: Zoe 9/13 – 10/2/52
To/Destination: Dupuy Foulkes & Co.,San Francisco, CA

Provenance:

H.J. Crocker, Atherton
Honolulu Academy of Arts
Honolulu Advertiser Collection
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 2

Certificates:

2-II-COV-73

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
Small tear at BR
Usage: On folded letter with 2¢ to New York City (see 1-II-COV-15)
Cancel on Stamp: 7-Bar Grid
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 10/4/52 SF 10/27/52
Vessel Dep/Arr: Mary A Jones 10/4 – 10/26/52
To/Destination: Dawson, New York, NY
Duplicate to Census No. 1-II-COV-15

Provenance:

N.E. Stamp Co. 1905
Worthington, Lichtenstein
Caspary, Mr. Phillips Collection
Ostheimer, Honolulu Advertiser
Giomparcaro Collection
Walske Collection
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 9, Realized $1,900,000
6/25/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Steven C. Walske Collection of Hawaiian Postal History, Sale 1045, Lot 11, Realized $1,950,000

Certificates:

2-I-COV-74
Sound

Notes:

Small wrinkle
Usage: On envelope
Cancel on Stamp: Large Grid of squares
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 10/20/53 SF 11/10/53
Vessel Dep/Arr: Zoe 10/22 – 11/9/53
To/Destination: Reynolds, Lancaster, PA

Provenance:

Found by relative, Economist Stamp Co.1923
Gibson Collection
Admiral Harris Collection
Philip G. Rust Collection
David Golden Collection
5/29/2016, William H. Gross Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The William H. Gross Collection: Hawaii, Sale 1126, Lot 6, Realized $85,000
6/30-7/1/2020, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2020 Rarities of the World, Sale 1224, Lot 284, Realized $80,000

Certificates:

PF (1994)
PF (2016)

2-II-COV-75

Notes:

Condition: Repaired
Corners defective and repaired; US stamps defective and repaired
Usage: Used on envelope US to Lahainaluna
Cancel on Stamp: Uncancelled
Honolulu/SF Pmks: None
To/Destination: Pouge, Lahainaluna

Provenance:

Atherton Collection

Certificates:

2-I-COV-76

Notes:

Condition: Minor Faults
Condition Notes: No repair, vertical crease and small tear at UL
Usage: On California Penny Post Co. entire
Cancel on Stamp: Uncancelled
Honolulu/SF Pmks: H 3/5/56 SF 3/21/56
Vessel Dep/Arr: Yankee 3/5 – 3/20/56
To/Destination: Noble & Haskell San Francisco, CA

Provenance:

Safﬁn, Honolulu Advertiser
11/7/1995, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Honolulu Advertiser Collection, Sale 769, Lot 10

Certificates:

Back to Census Summary of 2

Back to the Siegel Census

Copyright 2025. All rights reserved by Siegel Auction Galleries Inc. Information and images may be used with credit to Siegel Auction Galleries or siegelauctions.com subject to guidelines and restrictions.
Website Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Census of 5c Hawaiian Missionary (Scott HI2)62 Census Records

2-I-UNC-16

2-II-UNC-17

2-I-UNC-18

2-II-UNC-19 Fault

2-I-UNC-20

2-I-UNC-21

2-II-UNC-22

2-I-UNC-23

2-I-UNC-24

2-I-UNC-25

2-II-UNC-26

2-II-UNC-27 Sound

2-I-CAN-28

2-I-CAN-29

2-I-CAN-30

2-I-CAN-31

2-I-CAN-32

2-I-CAN-33

2-II-CAN-34

2-I-CAN-35 Sound

2-I-CAN-36

2-II-CAN-37

2-I-CAN-38

2-I-CAN-39

2-II-CAN-40

2-I-CAN-41

2-I-CAN-42

2-I-CAN-43

2-I-CAN-44

2-I-CAN-45

2-I-CAN-46

2-II-CAN-47

2-II-CAN-48

2-II-CAN-49

2-II-CAN-50

2-II-CAN-51

2-II-CAN-52

2-I-CAN-53

2-II-CAN-54

2-I-CAN-55

2-I-CAN-56

2-II-CAN-57

2-II-CAN-58

2-II-CAN-59 Fault

2-I-CAN-60

2-I-CAN-61

2-II-CAN-62

2-I-CAN-63

2-II-CAN-64

2-I-CAN-198

2-II-PCE-65

2-II-PCE-66

2-I-COV-67

2-I-COV-68

2-II-COV-69

2-I-COV-70

2-I-COV-71

2-II-COV-72 After file fold restoration

2-II-COV-73

2-I-COV-74 Sound

2-II-COV-75

2-I-COV-76

Census of 5c Hawaiian Missionary (Scott HI2)
62 Census Records

2-II-UNC-19
Fault

2-II-UNC-27
Sound

2-I-CAN-35
Sound

2-II-CAN-59
Fault

2-II-COV-72
After file fold restoration

2-I-COV-74
Sound